From Stone Tools to Society: How Prefrontal Cortex Evolution Refined Hominin stone tool making technique and Social Behaviour

Manish Kumar Rai , V.N. Mishra, Jose Rapheal, Pratik Pandey, Satyam Bharti, Neha Singh

Manish Kumar Rai

Department of Neurology, Institute of Medical Science, Banaras Hindu University- 221005, India

manishrai@bhu.ac.in

1. Abstract

The evolution of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) has been a pivotal factor in the emergence of cognitive abilities that distinguish early hominins from their primate relatives. The PFC, particularly its dorsolateral and ventromedial regions, is crucial for higher-order cognitive functions, such as planning, problem-solving, and social interactions. This research aims to review the development of the PFC and its correlation with human behavioral aspects, offering an integrative analysis of the neurological and archaeological evidence. The findings underscore the importance of neural development in the broader narrative of human evolutionary success, providing a comprehensive understanding of how cognitive and social complexities emerged in tandem with anatomical changes in the brain.

Keywords: Prefrontal cortex, Cognitive Development, Human Evolution, Stone Tool, Social behaviour

2. Introduction

The PFC is associated with higher cognitive processes known as executive functions, including Planning and Decision-Making which are Essential for creating complex tools (Euston, David R., 2012, Manes, F. et.al 2002, Krawczyk, D. C. 2002, Domenech & Koechli, 2015, Stout, D. et.al 2008, Putt, S. S. et.al 2019, Chakrabarty, M. 2019). These functions require forethought, understanding the sequence of steps, and anticipation of the final product. The ability to plan and make decisions is a hallmark of advanced cognitive function and is primarily associated with the prefrontal cortex (PFC). In the context of early hominins, these capabilities were crucial for the development of complex tool-making and sophisticated social behaviors (Stout, D. 2011, Cahen, D. et.al 1979, Klein, R. G. 2000, Henshilwood, C. S.  & Marean, C. W. 2003).  Here’s a deeper look into how the planning and decision-making functions of the PFC contributed to these evolutionary advancements. It also helps in the Sequential Task Management marked the Planning in Tool-Making (Keeley, L. H. 1980, Masclans, A. et.al 2017, Salls, R. A. 1985, Keeley, L. H. 1977). The complex tools require a series of steps that need to be executed in a specific order. For instance, shaping a stone tool involves selecting the right type of stone, striking it at precise angles, and refining its edges. The PFC allows for the organization and execution of these sequential tasks. Anticipation of Outcomes from this planning involves anticipating the end product and the steps needed to achieve it. Early hominins needed to visualize the final tool and plan backward from the desired outcome to the raw materials and actions required. The Resource Management associated with the PFC aids in managing resources, such as time and materials. Early tool-makers needed to decide how much effort to invest in creating a tool versus other survival activities, such as foraging or protecting themselves from predators. This also adds to the Problem-Solving skills in developing tools and techniques to solve practical problems (Waltz, J. A. et.al 1999, Kolb, B. et.al 2012, Fuster, J. 2015. Nonaka, T. et.al 2010, Stout, D et.al. 2008).

Problem-solving skills associated with the involvement of the Prefrontal Cortex in early Hominins are a critical part of the cognitive process for survival and adaptation in early hominins. Here's an exploration of how problem-solving abilities facilitated by the PFC contributed to the evolution of complex tool-making and social behaviors that may be analyzed the analysis amounts to identify the  ‘Needs and Goals’ of  Early hominins that faced various challenges that required solutions, such as accessing food, creating shelters, and protecting themselves from predators. The PFC helped identify these needs and set goals to address them. This also enabled them for that Innovative thinking often requires thinking outside the box. The PFC supports innovative thinking by enabling individuals to consider novel approaches and solutions. For instance, discovering that certain stones could be shaped into sharp tools required creative insight. Learning from Trial-and-Error Learning facilitates learning from past experiences. Early hominins could remember which techniques worked and which did not, refining their methods over time through trial and error.

The amount of Flexibility and Adaptability for Effective problem-solving requires the ability to adapt strategies when faced with new challenges. The PFC enables flexibility in thinking, allowing early hominins to adjust their approaches based on the situation and available resources. While dealing with the problems in the social context, Conflict Resolution is aided by PFC in resolving disputes by enabling individuals to consider multiple perspectives, negotiate, and find mutually acceptable solutions. The Cooperative Strategies in solving problems in a social context often involves cooperation. The PFC supports the ability to work together towards common goals, such as hunting large game or defending against predators, by coordinating efforts and sharing resources. While understanding the social dynamics the PFC helps individuals to interpret social cues, predict others' behavior, and devise strategies for social interactions. The Neural Mechanisms associated with the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex (DLPFC) Involved in working memory and cognitive flexibility plays an important role in decision-making. The DLPFC allows for the manipulation of information and the ability to switch between different strategies when solving problems. The Orbitofrontal Cortex (OFC) region is important for evaluating the outcomes of different actions and making decisions based on expected rewards and punishments. It helps in assessing the potential success of various problem-solving approaches. Another important factor is the Anterior Cingulate Cortex (ACC). It plays a role in error detection and conflict monitoring. It helps identify when a chosen strategy is not working and signals the need to adjust the approach. `While considering the evolutionary implications, Increased Survival Rates of the hominins depends on effective problem-solving. Early hominins who could devise solutions to challenges such as finding food, creating tools, and avoiding predators had higher survival rates. The Technological Advancements and the ability to solve problems led to technological innovations. The development of more effective tools and techniques improved efficiency in tasks like hunting, gathering, and building shelters. Social Cohesion and Group Success could resolve conflicts, cooperate effectively, and navigate social complexities had an advantage over less cohesive groups. Problem-solving skills and solutions were shared and passed down through generations. This transmission of knowledge contributed to cumulative cultural evolution, with each generation building on the advancements of the previous ones.

3. Objective of the research

The primary objective of this study is to elucidate the role of the PFC in the cognitive and social evolution of early hominins. By examining the relationship between encephalization and the sophistication of lithic technologies, this research seeks to demonstrate how the anatomical development of the PFC facilitated abstract thinking, complex social behavior, and the formation of cooperative structures that were essential for survival in challenging environments.

4. Methodology

To achieve this objective, a comprehensive review of both neurological and archaeological literature was conducted. The study integrates insights from paleoanthropology, neuroanatomy, and cognitive science to create a holistic understanding of the PFC's contribution to human evolution. The neurological analysis focuses on the structural and functional aspects of the PFC, particularly its dorsolateral and ventromedial regions, and how these areas have evolved over time. Concurrently, the archaeological review examines the correlation between the increasing encephalization in early hominins and the development of sophisticated lithic technologies, which serve as a proxy for cognitive advancements.

5. Discussion

The role of the prefrontal cortex (PFC) in the cognitive and social evolution of early hominins is multifaceted, encompassing critical functions such as inhibition, control, working memory, communication, imitation, and teaching.

(a) Inhibition and Control in the Prefrontal Cortex of Early Hominins

Inhibition and control, governed by the PFC, were essential for precise tool-making and managing social behaviors. The PFC enabled early hominins to regulate impulses, maintain focused attention, and engage in strategic planning—vital for executing complex tasks like tool-making. Socially, these cognitive abilities facilitated adherence to group norms, conflict management, and delayed gratification, which were crucial for maintaining social cohesion and cooperation.

(b) Holding Multiple Steps in Mind in the Prefrontal Cortex of Early Hominins

Working memory, another critical function of the PFC, allowed early hominins to hold multiple steps in mind, which was fundamental for complex tool-making. This capability enabled them to plan, execute, and refine sequential tasks. The PFC also supported problem-solving and the coordination of hands and tools, allowing for the adaptation of strategies when faced with challenges.

(c) Communication and the Prefrontal Cortex in Early Hominins

The PFC played a pivotal role in the evolution of communication, including the development of language and social interactions. Early hominins' ability to interpret social cues, manage conversations, and coordinate verbal and nonverbal communication was enhanced by the PFC, which facilitated more effective social interactions. The evolution of language, supported by neural mechanisms in the PFC, marked a significant milestone in human development, enabling complex social coordination and the transmission of knowledge.

(d) Imitation and Teaching and the Prefrontal Cortex in Early Hominins

Imitation and teaching, supported by the PFC, were crucial for cultural transmission and the development of social behaviors. The PFC enabled early hominins to observe, imitate, and refine behaviors, allowing for the transfer of knowledge across generations. This ability to learn from others and adapt to changing environments contributed to the development of complex cultural practices and technologies.

6. Conclusion

The prefrontal cortex's role in problem-solving was crucial for the evolution of early hominins. By enabling innovative thinking, adaptability, and effective social strategies, the PFC facilitated the development of complex tools and sophisticated social behaviors. Understanding these cognitive processes sheds light on the evolutionary paths that led to modern human capabilities. Inhibition and control, governed by the prefrontal cortex, were fundamental to the cognitive and social evolution of early hominins. These functions enabled precise tool-making, adherence to social norms, effective conflict management, and the development of complex social behaviors. Understanding these mechanisms provides insight into the evolutionary processes that shaped modern human cognition and society. The ability to hold multiple steps in mind, facilitated by the prefrontal cortex, was fundamental to the cognitive and social evolution of early hominins. This capability enabled the development of complex tools, sophisticated social behaviors, and the transmission of cultural knowledge. Understanding these mechanisms provides insight into the evolutionary processes that shaped modern human cognition and society.

The prefrontal cortex’s role in learning and refining techniques was crucial for the cognitive and cultural evolution of early hominins. By enabling the acquisition, improvement, and transmission of skills and knowledge, the PFC contributed to technological advancements, social complexity, and overall survival. Understanding these mechanisms provides insight into the evolutionary pathways that led to modern human behavior and society. Theory of Mind, supported by the prefrontal cortex, was a cornerstone in the evolution of early hominins. It enabled sophisticated social interactions, complex communication, and cultural transmission, all of which were crucial for the survival and success of our ancestors. Understanding the role of PFC provides valuable insights into the cognitive and social evolution that led to modern human behavior and society. Empathy and social norms, supported by the prefrontal cortex, were fundamental to the social and cognitive evolution of early hominins. These capabilities enabled the formation of cohesive social groups, effective cooperation, and the development of complex social structures. Understanding the role of empathy and social norms provides valuable insights into the evolutionary pathways that led to modern human societies and behaviors. The prefrontal cortex's role in managing complex social interactions was crucial for the evolution of early hominins. By supporting cooperation, communication, understanding of social hierarchies, and moral decision-making, the PFC enabled the development of sophisticated social structures and cultural practices. Understanding these mechanisms provides insight into the evolutionary processes that shaped human societies and behaviors. Communication, supported by the prefrontal cortex, was a critical factor in the cognitive and social evolution of early hominins. By enabling sophisticated language development, social interactions, and the coordination of verbal and nonverbal cues, the PFC facilitated cooperation, cultural transmission, and the establishment of complex social structures. Understanding these mechanisms provides insight into the evolutionary processes that shaped human societies and behaviors. Symbolic thinking, supported by the prefrontal cortex, was a key factor in the cognitive and cultural evolution of early hominins. By enabling the use and understanding of symbols, early hominins could develop complex language, art, technology, and social structures. This cognitive ability facilitated cultural transmission, technological innovation, and the establishment of intricate social systems, shaping the trajectory of human evolution. Imitation and teaching, supported by the prefrontal cortex, were crucial for the cognitive and cultural evolution of early hominins. These processes facilitated the acquisition and transmission of skills, knowledge, and cultural practices, contributing to the development of complex societies and technologies. Understanding the role of imitation and teaching provides valuable insights into the evolutionary pathways that shaped human behavior and cultural development.

7. Reference

1. Euston, David R., et al. "The Role of Medial Prefrontal Cortex in Memory and Decision Making." Neuron, vol. 76, no. 6, 2012, pp. 1057-1070.

2. Manes, F., et al. "Decision‐Making Processes Following Damage to the Prefrontal Cortex." Brain, vol. 125, no. 3, 2002, pp. 624-639.

3. Krawczyk, Daniel C. "Contributions of the Prefrontal Cortex to the Neural Basis of Human Decision Making." Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, vol. 26, no. 6, 2002, pp. 631-664.

4. Domenech, Philippe, and Etienne Koechlin. "Executive Control and Decision-Making in the Prefrontal Cortex." Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, vol. 1, 2015, pp. 101-106.

5. Stout, Dietrich, et al. "Neural Correlates of Early Stone Age Toolmaking: Technology, Language and Cognition in Human Evolution." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, vol. 363, no. 1499, 2008, pp. 1939-1949.

6. Putt, Suzanna S., et al. "Prefrontal Cortex Activation Supports the Emergence of Early Stone Age Toolmaking Skill." NeuroImage, vol. 199, 2019, pp. 57-69.

7. Chakrabarty, Moinak. "How Stone Tools Shaped Us: Post-Phenomenology and Material Engagement Theory." Philosophy & Technology, vol. 32, no. 2, 2019, pp. 243-264.

8. Stout, Dietrich. "Stone Toolmaking and the Evolution of Human Culture and Cognition." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, vol. 366, no. 1567, 2011, pp. 1050-1059.

9. Cahen, Daniel, et al. "Stone Tools, Toolkits, and Human Behavior in Prehistory [and Comments and Reply]." Current Anthropology, vol. 20, no. 4, 1979, pp. 661-683.

10. Klein, Richard G. "Archeology and the Evolution of Human Behavior." Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews, vol. 9, no. 1, 2000, pp. 17-36.

11. Henshilwood, Christopher S., and Curtis W. Marean. "The Origin of Modern Human Behavior: Critique of the Models and Their Test Implications." Current Anthropology, vol. 44, no. 5, 2003, pp. 627-651.

12. Keeley, Lawrence H. Experimental Determination of Stone Tool Uses: A Microwear Analysis. University of Chicago Press, 1980.

13. Masclans, Ariadna, et al. "Functional Studies of Neolithic Stone Axes and Adzes. Experimental Program and Archaeological Applications." Cuadernos de Prehistoria y Arqueología de la Universidad de Granada, vol. 27, 2017, pp. 177-210.

14. Salls, Richard A. "The Scraper Plane: A Functional Interpretation." Journal of Field Archaeology, vol. 12, no. 1, 1985, pp. 99-106.

15. Keeley, Lawrence H. "The Functions of Paleolithic Flint Tools." Scientific American, vol. 237, no. 5, 1977, pp. 108-127.

16. Waltz, James A., et al. "A System for Relational Reasoning in Human Prefrontal Cortex." Psychological Science, vol. 10, no. 2, 1999, pp. 119-125.

17. Kolb, Bryan, et al. "Experience and the Developing Prefrontal Cortex." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 109, supplement 2, 2012, pp. 17186-17193.

18. Fuster, Joaquin. The Prefrontal Cortex. Academic Press, 2015.

19. Nonaka, Tetsuro, et al. "How Do Stone Knappers Predict and Control the Outcome of Flaking? Implications for Understanding Early Stone Tool Technology." Journal of Human Evolution, vol. 59, no. 2, 2010, pp. 155-167.

20. Stout, Dietrich, et al. "Neural Correlates of Early Stone Age Toolmaking: Technology, Language and Cognition in Human Evolution." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, vol. 363, no. 1499, 2008, pp. 1939-1949.